Articles

Replacing E-commerce Operators in China: Secure the Right to Terminate First.

6 min read By rpadmin
Local expertise.
Global perspective.

Lessons from an arbitration on contract termination and business handover

By Chen Yun and Fabian Knopf

A brand may hold the registration for its China online store and own the inventory, yet still struggle to replace its e-commerce operator without disrupting sales. In an arbitration we handled, an international brand ultimately won its case but, but it took about a year to recover nearly CNY 100 million worth of its own inventory. An express contractual right to terminate without cause reduces legal uncertainty. The contract should also address how the brand can regain control of its operations and secure the release of its inventory when that right is exercised.

What happened

The brand replaced its China e-commerce operator. As the agreement with the replaced operator did not provide for termination without cause, the replaced operator disputed the brand’s right to terminate and maintained that the agreement remained in force. It requested continued performance and restoration of its platform access. The tribunal confirmed the agreement had terminated, rejected both requests and ordered the handover of assets the replaced operator still held.

The brand’s position differed sharply by asset:

AssetWho controlled itResult
Online storeBrand (held the store registration)Brand removed the operator’s access itself; the switch was manageable
Inventory, nearly CNY 100 millionReplaced operator (contracted and managed the warehouse)The replaced operator and warehouse did not release the goods when the brand requested collection; goods returned about a year later, shortly before the award
Customer groups and other assetsReplaced operatorThe tribunal ordered the replaced operator to transfer the customer groups and other assets to the brand

The delay spanned several major online sales campaigns. For food, cosmetics and other products with limited shelf lives, such delays increase the risk of products nearing expiry or requiring markdowns. For imported goods, long production and import lead times may prevent blocked stock from being replaced quickly.

The lesson: ownership is not control. Brands must also consider who controls platform access, customer groups and the release of inventory.

Four contractual safeguards for a smoother exit

An express right to terminate without cause is critical because it allows the brand to exit without having to establish a breach. Effective control and handover arrangements are also essential to ensure a smooth transition.

TermRisk without itWhat to negotiate
1. Right to terminate without causeIf exit depends on proving breach, the operator can dispute the breach, its seriousness and the cure periodexpress right to terminate without cause on reasonable advance notice; clear financial consequences, ideally with no compensation for exercising that rightagreed option to pay in lieu of notice;separate termination triggers for breach, missed targets, unauthorized subcontracting, serious compliance failures and changes of control, with cure periods where appropriate
2. Control of the storeChanging operators may require a change of store entity or a new store, subject to platform ruleswhere platform rules permit, the brand or an eligible group entity holds the store registration, receives sales proceeds and controls the primary account;operator receives revocable permissions under the service model discussed here
3. Control of inventoryOwnership alone does not give the brand authority to direct the warehouse or secure release of the goodsbrand contracts directly with the warehouse where practicable and retains authority to instruct stock counts, transfers and release; OR,tripartite agreement or warehouse acknowledgment specifies when the warehouse must follow the brand’s instructions
4. Specific handover obligationsA general duty to “cooperate with the handover” leaves essential details open to disputedefined tasks, responsible parties and deadlines; participation by the replacement operator;obligation to continue the handover despite fee disputes and liability for failure to comply with handover obligations

The operating agreement, warehousing arrangements and platform authorizations should align on notice periods, termination dates and instruction rights. The warehouse must have clear instructions on when to stop accepting directions from the outgoing operator and start accepting them from the brand or its replacement.

Why the law alone is not enough

Under PRC law, a contract may be terminated on statutory grounds or as agreed by the parties. Two provisions of the Civil Code deserve particular attention in e-commerce operating agreements.

  • Article 580(2) allows a party to seek termination through a court or arbitral tribunal where a statutory exception to continued performance of a nonmonetary obligation prevents the contractual purpose from being achieved. A breakdown of trust and the appointment of a replacement operator, as in the case above, may be relevant but do not automatically satisfy these requirements. Also. termination does not eliminate liability for breach.
  • Article 933 allows either party to terminate an entrustment contract at any time. Whether an e-commerce operating agreement qualifies as an entrustment contract may be open to different interpretations. In the case above, the tribunal did not treat the agreement covering store operations, warehousing and logistics as a straightforward entrustment contract. Even where Article 933 applies, termination of a paid entrustment contract without justifiable cause may require compensation for direct losses and the benefits the other party would have obtained had the contract been performed.

These provisions illustrate why statutory grounds for termination may not offer the certainty a brand needs when replacing an operator. Brands should therefore secure an express contractual right to terminate without cause. While the Civil Code provides general rules on post-termination obligations, the contract should also establish clear arrangements for the transition of operations and the handover of assets.

Conclusion

E-commerce operating agreements are typically negotiated when both parties expect the relationship to succeed. Sales targets, commissions and marketing budgets naturally receive close attention. The possibility of an eventual exit should also be addressed from the outset.

Brands should secure:

  1. an express right to terminate without cause,
  2. effective control over their stores and inventory, and
  3. clear, enforceable handover obligations.

These protections can reduce the risk of prolonged disputes and business disruption.

An arbitral award can confirm a brand’s rights and help recover its assets. It cannot undo the business disruption caused by a delayed handover.


R&P advises overseas brand owners on China e-commerce operational arrangements, contract structuring and dispute resolution. We help brands design robust exit, termination and inventory handover terms to mitigate disruption risks when changing local e-commerce operators. For more information, please reach out to Chen Yun ([email protected]) or Fabian Knopf ([email protected]), or your usual contact at R&P China Lawyers.

Speak with our team

Discuss your business in China.

Clear advice starts with understanding your situation. Tell us what you are facing and we will connect you with the right people at R&P.

Email our team